Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Letter to the Editor, take 2

Written in response to Daily Universe Article (page 8, "Hospital Births a Safe Option)

Hospital births are not necessarily the safest option for a majority of mothers. In cases of non-complicated pregnancies, a non-intervention birth at home may be a safer alternative. Medical procedures that have come to be the norm in our society can actually put both the mother and baby at risk. First of all, more than 2/3 of laboring mothers in the United States opt for a pain-relieving epidural. In many cases, obstetricians will not even allow the mother a choice. However, epidurals affect birthing hormones, slowing down labor in many cases. As a result of the slowed labor, the doctors will administer pitocin, a synthetic form of the hormone oxytocin, increasing the intensity and frequency of uterine contractions. And quite reminiscent of our rushed culture, if the mother still does not progress in her labor, she will be convinced that the best thing for her and the baby would be a c-section. However, the reality is the c-section is the best thing for that obstetrician; c-sections are the most lucrative, efficient, and litigiously safe way to bring children into the world by the standard of the doctor. No wonder the American College of OB/GYNS denounces home births... perhaps there are some vested interests there? It is not taken into account that a c-section also increases the risk of infection and hemorrhage (and death), prolongs recovery, and inhibits breastfeeding initiation. But aren't we missing out on the beauty and spirituality of childbirth? We thank the doctor for "delivering the baby," but shouldn't we be praising the mother for her blood sacrifice? Our conception of childbirth must be rethought before we turn it into some weird medical, scientific phenomenon, and forget about what a supernal gift it is given to women by their God.

6 comments:

TheMoncurs said...

Why would they even write an article about that? Was there ever anyone who said, "Hospitals are a really dangerous place to give birth! Avoid them at all costs!"

I agree with your post, but also add the caveat that it all sooo depends on your practitioner. Some really are the types to hurry you through because they've got places to go, people to see, money to make.

But some are willing to sit back and let you do your thing. They are pretty much there to catch when you're ready and to watch for problems. If you have a doctor like that it doesn't matter where you give birth, you'll get to do it your way!

Anonymous said...

I love this post Caitlin! I keep telling people I don't want an epidural and everyone tells me I can't do it without one- they obviously don't know me very well. If my 5' 100 lbs mother did it that way for 5 kids, why can't I?


I'm not even pregnant, but this made me think about that. Damn the naysayers--do you have any good links for information on home birthing?

Lauren said...

When you have all had BABIES without EPIDURALS, then you can talk about natural child birth! Until then, I don't want to hear it. :)

Caitlin Carroll said...

Hey now Lauren... no one said it was easy. Women do it every day though... in developing and Western countries. Who says we can't do it? I say it's better for my body and my baby, then the pain will not matter. There are so many adverse consequences from epidurals, why risk it?

Unknown said...

I absolutely agree, and I'm a mom who labored naturally for over 35 hours.

http://www.xanga.com/mmmelody

Anonymous said...

Caitlin,

Cait...Cait...Cait...
I believe women can have as little intervention as they want. And it really depends on the physician and facility where you choose to deliver. An open mind to options is never a bad thing. Initial plans not to have an epidural, not to have an IV, not to have monitoring are fine. But until you have had some labor pains- keep your options open. There are two ways to have a baby- vaginal and c/s. For some c/s is necessary and if it saved you or your child wouldn't it be worth the risk? As for having your baby at home- STUPID!!!!! As a labor and delivery nurse for 10 years I have seen bad things happen when people don't have access to "weird medical, scientific phenomenon."
I had 3 epidurals and loved them all. I did not miss out on the beauty or spirituality of birth. Only on the pain!!
Thanks anyway but bring on the pain meds.
I love you!
Aunt Olivia